Cherry replanting can be challenging and presents a significant issue for farmers, primarily due to “replant disease.” This condition, characterized by reduced tree vigor and yield, is often attributed to plant-parasitic nematodes and other soil quality factors. A two-year study conducted in the United States on two sweet cherry cultivars, “Emperor Francis” and “Ulster,” analyzed six different soil treatment strategies to identify the best solutions for improving tree growth and managing nematodes.
Among the strategies evaluated, fumigation with a mixture of 1,3-dichloropropene and chloropicrin (Telone® C-35) proved particularly effective in enhancing early tree growth. This treatment significantly increased trunk cross-sectional area (TCSA) and canopy height in both cultivars. Fumigation also drastically reduced populations of the nematode Pratylenchus penetrans in the short term, creating optimal conditions for plant development.
However, the study revealed that fumigation efficacy declines over time, with the nematode reproduction factor (RF) rising again in the second year. This finding suggests that while fumigation is initially beneficial, it needs to be supplemented with other practices to ensure long-term control.
An alternative strategy is the use of fluopyram (Velum® Prime), a non-fumigant nematicide that demonstrated greater persistence in controlling Pratylenchus penetrans. Over the two years of the study, fluopyram consistently maintained a reproduction factor below one, indicating effective and lasting nematode population control.
Furthermore, trees treated with fluopyram exhibited growth comparable to those treated with Telone® C-35, making it a viable option for those seeking a less invasive but equally effective approach.
Organic amendments, such as Dairy Doo®, Seed Starter 101®, and straw mulch, yielded varying results. While their immediate impact on tree growth was less pronounced compared to chemical treatments, these amendments significantly improved soil quality by increasing populations of bacterivorous and fungivorous nematodes.
These organisms play a vital role in maintaining a balanced soil ecosystem, thereby promoting overall plant health. The combination of Dairy Doo®, Seed Starter 101®, and straw mulch also demonstrated some effectiveness in reducing Pratylenchus penetrans populations in the second year, suggesting that organic amendments can offer long-term benefits if used consistently.
Despite their advantages, organic amendments require repeated applications to maintain their effectiveness over time. Their action is influenced by factors such as soil temperature and moisture, which affect decomposition rates and the availability of bioactive nematicidal compounds. Additionally, their ability to support beneficial nematodes depends on the quality and quantity of organic matter applied.
In conclusion, sustainable cherry replanting management requires an integrated approach that combines chemical and organic treatments. Telone® C-35 (mixture of 1,3-dichloropropene and chloropicrin) is ideal for rapid and effective initial nematode control, while Velum® Prime (fluopyram) provides a more enduring solution.
Organic amendments, though requiring more effort in terms of application, contribute to improving soil health and promoting biodiversity. Integrating these strategies can ensure higher productivity while minimizing environmental impact. Further research should focus on optimizing treatment combinations to maximize both agronomic and ecological benefits.
Source: Yaghoubi, A., Yazdani, R., Cole, E., & Quintanilla, M. (2024). Pre-Plant Soil Treatments Influence Tree Performance and Nematode Dynamics in Replanted Cherry Orchards. Plant Disease, (ja). https://doi.org/10.1094/PDIS-06-24-1178-RE.
Images: SL Fruit Service
Andrea Giovannini
University of Bologna (IT)
01 Jun 2023
The production of sour cherries in the Modena area (Italy) has strong and recognised identity and territorial characteristics; today mainly conducted according to extensive processes, it can benefit from an evolution towards more efficient and sustainable innovative systems.
11 Jul 2024
In a recent study, researchers explored how ABA modulates these ripening processes at both genetic and epigenetic levels through RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) and whole-genome bisulfite sequencing (WGBS).
25 Sep 2026
Sweet cherry nutrition and fruit quality: studies from Chile, USA, Spain and other countries show how nitrogen, potassium, calcium, boron, phosphorus and magnesium affect fruit size, firmness, soluble solids, color, cracking and postharvest storage performance.
25 Sep 2026
The velvet longhorned beetle, Trichoferus campestris, is an invasive wood-boring beetle detected in Utah, Illinois, Minnesota and other US states. It can infest dry wood and many tree hosts, including apple, cherry and peach, while its long-term impact remains uncertain.
