Controlling San José Scale with new chemicals: a possible solution?

03 Jun 2024
3520

The San Josè scale (Quadraspidiotus perniciosus) secondary pest mainly affects apples, pears, peaches plums; however, also cherries sour cherries cannot escape attacks by this insect. It is a parasite that sucks sap for food and introduces a toxic substance into the plant that causes localised discolouration. Moreover, the reddish spots observed on the fruit during harvesting suggest the presence of potentially harmful quantities on the trees.

However, the damage is not only limited to the fruit: if not managed correctly, the San José scale can cause the death of branches or even the entire tree within a few years. This is why it is necessary to investigate possible chemical means of controlling this insect in the field.

The aim of the study conducted at the Trevor Nichols Research Center of Michigan State University (USA) was to evaluate the effectiveness of two San Josè scale defence programmes in sour cherry; they involved the use of Sivanto Prime 200SL and flupyradifuron 300SL. The efficacy of these two treatments was compared with an untreated control and a treatment with a standard commercial product (Centaur 70WDG).

The orchard in which the experiment was conducted was located at the Fennville Experiment Station (USA), on a 13-year-old sour cherry orchard cv ‘Balaton’. Application of the test products was conducted using two methods:

  • a tractor-mounted FMC 1029 compressed air sprayer, calibrated to deliver 100 gallons per acre at a rate of 2.5 miles per hour.
  • a CO2-powered single-tree soil spraying system.

Before and after the soil spraying treatment, the soil was wetted with water. Sivanto 300SL was administered with a dose of 2 litres of water per tree. The following canopy maintenance applications were also carried out during the growing season: Actara, Bravo WeatherStik, Captan 80, Luna Flex and Luna Sensation. Herbicides 2-4 D, Alion, Diuron, Glyphosate and Solicam were used in a concentrated manner under the trees to manage weed growth.

A preliminary count of the number of live San Jose scale on each plot was conducted on 17 May by observing 25 shoots taken randomly. The shoots were then observed again on 20 June and 2 October using the same method as the pre-treatment count. The results are presented as the average number of scales per plot.

From these, it can be seen that Centaur was the only treatment that significantly reduced the occurrence of San Josè scale on sour cherry shoots during the 2 October evaluation, compared to the untreated control. Although the treatment programmes with Sivanto and flupyradifuron reduced the occurrence of the insect by more than 50% compared to the untreated control, the results did not show statistical significance.

The ability of the flupyradifuron treatment to penetrate the vascular system of the tree may have been slightly hampered by the unusually dry period that occurred after application, which is uncommon in Michigan. Due to the slow onset of action of the treatments, no notable differences were detected during the 20 June evaluation. Thus, research cannot be stopped: new and alternative solutions needs to be found!

Source: Amber K DeVisser, Celeste E Wheeler, Julianna Wilson, John C Wise, Control of San Jose scale in tart cherry, 2023, Arthropod Management Tests, Volume 49, Issue 1, 2024, tsad140, https://doi.org/10.1093/amt/tsad140.
Image: CABI

Melissa Venturi
University of Bologna (IT)


Cherry Times - All rights reserved

What to read next

How 1-MCP extends sweet cherry shelf life: tests on Kordia and Regina in Poland

Post-harvest​

18 Sep 2025

A recent study in Poland confirms the effectiveness of 1-MCP in extending sweet cherry shelf life. The treatment reduces weight loss and preserves visual and nutritional quality. Promising results for Kordia and Regina varieties after 21 days in cold storage.

Organic and conventional sour cherries compared: three years of data highlight the decisive role of cultivar and climate

Tech management

26 Jun 2026

A three-year study in Poland compares organic and conventional sour cherries, showing that cultivar, climate and season affect fruit quality more than orchard management alone. Oblačinska stands out as the most promising cultivar for high-quality organic production.

In evidenza

Extreme weather conditions and a transport strike are threatening the cherry season

Markets

13 Nov 2026

Rain and hail in Chile have damaged crops, while a truckers’ strike in San Antonio threatens shipments. Cherry output could reach about 115 million boxes, below the 140 million estimate. Weather and logistics are clouding the 2026-2027 season and its export outlook.

Cherry leaf curl virus: how to recognise and prevent it

Crop protection

13 Nov 2026

Cherry leaf roll virus affects sweet, sour and black cherry trees. It is regulated in Canada, where symptoms may appear about five years after infection. The article outlines how it spreads and measures to prevent its introduction and contain the virus in orchards.

Tag Popolari