Pollination in the time of cover nets: what fate for bees?

25 Jun 2024
908

Protected cultivation systems have been rapidly adopted worldwide due to the advances they have brought in agricultural production. Although the implications of using these systems on the plant (to increase its growth and productivity) have been extensively studied, the aspects related to pollinating insects are still poorly understood.

The services provided by pollinating insects, however, are essential for maintaining ecological stability as well as fruit and vegetable production. It is estimated that over 75 per cent of cereals require pollination, accounting for one third of the global food supply. Previous studies have identified that covers such as bird nets and polythene covers have a negative impact on honey bee activity.

This decrease in activity has been attributed to a number of critical factors, such as increased temperatures and humidity, increased exposure to pesticides, changing light levels and UV transmittance (which disrupts the flight of these insects), physical damage or entanglement in nets, reduced pollen and nectar availability, and low floral diversity.

The health and effectiveness of honey bees (Apis mellifera L.) during pollination of sweet cherry crops were examined in the study conducted in Tasmania, Australia, using bird nets and polythene rain covers. Twelve bee colonies were fitted with radio frequency identification systems (RFID) and bees were tagged during two consecutive seasons.

The colonies were equally distributed between the following groups: open control, anti-bird net and polythene (semi-permanent VOEN in 2019 and retractable Cravo in 2020). Behavioural parameters, including foraging onset age, number and duration of visits and overall survival, were monitored throughout the commercial pollination period, involving more than 1300 bees.

The results demonstrated the variability of microclimatic conditions at the various colony sites. In particular, temperature was higher in VOEN systems, while wind speed and solar radiation were higher in the absence of cover. In all cover types, bees started foraging within the optimal age range (mean 15.7-24.1 days), with minimal evidence of increased mortality or prolonged stress during the short season.

The total time required for bees to forage effectively was significantly increased by polythene covers (VOEN & Cravo). Bees from hives placed under cover made up to 155% more foraging excursions and had a longer cumulative duration. The amount and type of pollen collected was substantially influenced by the type of cover, with the most restrictive system (VOEN) producing the highest percentage of cherry pollen.

Overall, this study stands in stark contrast to previous studies showing that the protective covers tested do not have a negative effect on the foraging behaviour of bees in cherry trees. This is only a starting point: further research is needed to fully understand the impact of protective covers on pollinators, as crop diversity and the area of land covered continue to expand rapidly. Sustainable food production is at risk as the availability of pollinators for crop pollination continues to decline.

It is therefore imperative to optimise cultivation conditions to facilitate effective crop pollination and pollinator survival. We aspire that future canopy systems prioritise bee welfare in their design

Source: Warren, R. J., Colin, T., Quarrell, S. R., Barron, A. B., & Allen, G. R. (2024). Quantifying the impact of crop coverings on honey bee orientation and foraging in sweet cherry orchards using RFID. Journal of Applied Entomology, 148, 566–581. https://doi.org/10.1111/jen.13247.
Image: SL Fruit Service

Melissa Venturi
University of Bologna (IT)


Cherry Times - All rights reserved

What to read next

In Vignola (IT) a study against Drosophila suzukii to improve quality and sustainability

Crop protection

17 Apr 2024

Initial results show that the Attract & Kill strategy combined with multifunctional nets can reduce the use of insecticides while providing effective protection. The programme will continue in 2024 with the extension of the experimental field in Vignola.

In Otago, an experimental project on freezing cherries promises new opportunities for the New Zealand market

Post-harvest​ Quality Press review

29 Jan 2024

Every year an average of 2,207 tonnes of Central Otago cherries are discarded or not harvested due to imperfections. Eden Orchards, known for its juices, has experimented with individual freezing of cherries in an attempt to develop a commercially viable process.

In evidenza

Turkey increases cherry and sour cherry production: new sustainable asphalt applications

Processed

01 Aug 2025

Turkey’s cherry and sour cherry production rises, prompting innovative ways to manage waste. Çurkova and Ege universities explore biochar from cherry residues to enhance asphalt durability and sustainability, supporting eco-friendly infrastructure.

Dried cherry production in Chile: GoodValley strategy and global markets

Processed

01 Aug 2025

Dried cherry production in Chile is growing with GoodValley, aiming to reduce waste and enhance value. From the Colchagua Valley to Asia, the strategy focuses on expanding exports and finding markets for an innovative and increasingly appreciated product.

Tag Popolari