Production collapse in Michigan: eradication of sour cherry plants continues

23 Jan 2024
2059

64-year-old Doug White, a third-generation farmer in northwestern Lower Michigan, made a difficult decision.  His farm, once dotted with cherry trees positioned like soldiers in the fields, now presented desolate empty spaces. White, visibly concerned, expressed his feeling of guilt over this difficult decision, looking out onto the veranda of his house.

The situation in the cherry industry has been a struggle for White and many other growers. In north-western Lower Michigan, 70-75% of US cherry production is grown, mainly in areas such as northeast of Traverse City. In 2022, Michigan produced 180 million pounds of cherries, but this year's crop is estimated at 120.5 million pounds, marking a contraction in the industry.

The main problems faced by farmers include the low prices received for cherries, which fell from an average of 35.4 cents per pound 20 years ago to about 20 cents this year. This situation will persist from 2017 to 2021, with production costs estimated at between 40 and 44 cents per pound. Doug White, together with his brothers, had been running the cow, cherry and apple farm, but the situation prompted him to take drastic measures.

White decided to divide some of his land into five-acre lots and rent them out to the Traverse City Horse Show (TCHS), a growing equestrian event that has had a significant impact on the region, awarding over $7 million in prizes and generating an economic impact of $128.4 million.

Competition with cheap imports, especially from Turkey, exacerbated the situation. A federal marketing order created in 1997 to stabilise cherry prices proved ineffective when imports from Turkey, the world leader in cherry production, flooded the US market with subsidised products.

Efforts by Michigan growers and processors in 2019 to file a petition against Turkey for dumping practices were unsuccessful. Despite a preliminary tariff applied by the Department of Commerce, the ITC overturned the decision in 2020, causing disappointment among growers.

Weather problems, including mild winters followed by deadly frosts, have affected the production of cherries and other fresh fruit in Michigan. Harvest losses over the past 20 years have been frequent, threatening an industry that generates over $485 million annually. Michigan State University Extension expert Nikki Rothwell pointed out that Michigan cherries have become a symbol of climate change, with abnormal weather affecting production.

Crop insurance, established in 2014, provides some relief, but with continued losses, the basis on which it is based takes a hit. White, contemplating his retirement, will sell part of his land, keeping 4 hectares to grow pumpkins and offer children the opportunity to pick them for free.

White's conclusion is pessimistic about the future of the cherry industry, highlighting the lack of support and the difficulty of competing with subsidised imports. His experience reflects the challenges faced by many growers in a shrinking and concentrated industry.

Source: Farm Progress
Image: Farm Progress


Cherry Times - All rights reserved

What to read next

New markers for the genetic selection of flowering time in cherry trees

Breeding

03 Sep 2024

The aim of an investigation conducted in the Czech Republic was to identify molecular markers that could be relied upon to predict the onset of flowering in sweet cherries by creating an assay that analysed the identified molecular markers in a single reaction.

How altitude influences sweet cherry quality: study on four cultivars

Quality

01 Apr 2025

Altitude changes the quality of cherries, affecting organic acids and phenolic compounds. A study in Turkey on four cultivars grown at 200 and 800 m revealed changes in the nutritional profile, improving flavour and antioxidant properties of the fruit.

In evidenza

Colchagua beats Ovalle: ultra-early cherries kick off 2025/26 season

Production

17 Oct 2025

Chile's 2025/26 cherry season starts with a surprise: Colchagua beats Ovalle with AG2, harvested on October 13. 3J and 4J-sized cherries are already on their way to China. Meanwhile, the north kicks off its harvest with Brooks and Nimba, determined not to fall behind.

The expert informs: fertilisation and irrigation of the cherry tree. Strategies for soil, roots and fruit quality

Tech management

17 Oct 2025

Technical guide to optimize cherry yield through precise irrigation, fertilization, and soil structure management. Strategies to enhance root activity, prevent compaction, and ensure high-quality, consistent fruit production season after season with sustainable practices.

Tag Popolari