A legal dispute between Canada and the United States over the patented cherry variety Staccato™ reveals three key lessons about the protection of fruit varieties and intellectual property rights in the agricultural sector.
In the world of fruit and vegetable production, extending a fruit's marketing window by even one week can mean extra profits and strategic advantages. Cherry growers know this well, and for them, the Staccato™ cherry lawsuit sets a crucial precedent in the field of plant patents.
It all began in Summerland, British Columbia, where Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada (AAFC) experts developed a new late-ripening cherry variety. Staccato ripens about 30 days after Bing cherries, allowing for late-season sales at higher prices. However, in the United States, a grower allegedly marketed the variety under the name “Glory,” claiming to be its originator.
This led to a long legal battle to defend U.S. plant patent no. 20,551, which was initially invalidated but recently reinstated by a court, strengthening the position of the Canadian government.
An often overlooked aspect is the legal nature of a plant patent. It is a form of intellectual property granted in the United States since 1930, protecting asexually reproduced plant varieties. It differs from utility patents or registered trademarks.
In agriculture, however, this tool is still underutilized: in 2024, about 1,000 plant patents were granted compared to more than 350,000 regular patents.
In addition to plant patents, there are two main alternatives:
Those who develop new fruit varieties must understand the differences between plant patents, breeder’s rights, utility patents, and trademarks. Each tool has its own requirements, benefits, and limitations. In Canada, for example, Plant Breeders’ Rights are used, while in the U.S., the plant patent applies to asexual plants.
The Staccato case was initially compromised by an Excel sheet listing sales predating the patent application. It was later revealed that the cherries sold were not Staccato. Keeping accurate records of sales and disclosures is crucial to preserve a variety’s novelty and withstand legal challenges.
A legal team skilled in agricultural intellectual property law can make a difference in court. In the Staccato case, the U.S. grower even waived the right to a jury trial, making Canada’s win easier. At the filing stage too, it's essential to work with specialized plant patent consultants.
The Staccato™ cherry case is emblematic for any agricultural business investing in varietal innovation. Whether it's cherries, apples, grapes, or berries, protecting a new variety means gaining a tangible competitive and commercial advantage.
From recordkeeping to choosing the right IP protection type and selecting the right advisors, the Staccato™ story shows how strategic careful management of intellectual property is in agriculture. It’s not just a concern for large companies: every grower investing in new varieties or techniques should protect their know-how.
And while not everyone has a cherry to defend in court, it’s just as true that those who work the land must learn to protect what grows… on paper.
Source: perpetualmotionpatents.com
Cover image source: Yury Farm - SL FRUIT SERVICE
Internal image source: Hortinvest - SL FRUIT SERVICE
23 Apr 2025
Discover how volatile compounds from sour cherry fruits are changing the fight against Rhagoletis cerasi. A study in Lithuania identifies effective natural attractants for mass trapping—ideal for organic, sustainable fruit farming in Europe and North America.
31 Oct 2024
Producers have several management strategies to increase the final fruit size, including fruit load regulation, irrigation management, fertilisation and the application of biostimulants and growth regulators.
23 Jun 2026
The study on 0900 Ziraat sweet cherries shows that calcium chloride, glycine betaine and chitosan can reduce fruit cracking to 1.6%, while improving resistance, nutritional quality, antioxidant activity and pre-harvest fruit stability under orchard conditions in trials.
23 Jun 2026
The first PDO picota cherries from Valle del Jerte have received seasonal certification. In Extremadura, the campaign begins with strong prospects for quality and volume, despite rain damage affecting some cherry varieties protected by the Cereza del Jerte PDO label.
