Biocontrol of brown rot on cherry and plum: e5icacy, limitations and prospects

25 Jul 2025
3247

Brown rot is a disease caused by several fungi belonging to the Monilinia genus, with Monilinia laxa being the primary species. This fungal disease is among the most problematic aBecting cherry and plum, with significant impacts on fruit quality and post-harvest losses.

A recent study, aiming to identify alternative and more sustainable solutions to conventional chemical treatments, analyzed the eBicacy of various biopesticides, fungicides, and indigenous microbial strains for disease containment.

The study evaluated five commercial biopesticides: BioPK, BoniProtect, Trianum, PreStop, and Serenade, along with two unformulated local strains, Bacillus subtilis B91 and Aureobasidium pullulans Y126, comparing them with Indar (a fungicide based on fenbuconazole) and Rovral, used as control treatments.

Application conditions and results

The products were tested at two application times: before (preventive) or after (curative) pathogen inoculation; and under three diBerent conditions: artificially inoculated fruits, non-sterilized fruits with natural infections, and during storage at controlled temperature (1°C) or at room temperature (ca. 20°C).

The results confirmed the high eBicacy of Indar, which completely inhibited M. laxa infection in both cherries and plums, regardless of application timing, cultivar, or wound type.

In contrast, most commercial biopesticides showed limited eBicacy. Only Serenade, based on B. subtilis QST 713, demonstrated partial activity when applied preventively.

The local strains B91 and Y126 also exhibited inhibitory action, but only under cold conditions (1°C). However, their eBectiveness dropped drastically when the treated fruit was subsequently exposed to room temperature for one week, highlighting limitations in the persistence and competitiveness of biocontrol under dynamic post-harvest conditions.

Limits of post-harvest applications

In post-harvest tests on naturally infected fruits, none of the biocontrol treatments reduced disease incidence. Only Rovral achieved a statistically significant, though modest, reduction.

This indicates that in the presence of latent infections originating in the field, post-harvest applications are ineBective. Pre-harvest treatments proved to be the only biological strategy capable of reducing such infections and mitigating storage losses.

The study also showed that environmental conditions strongly influence outcomes: low post-harvest temperatures slowed the development of M. laxa and favored biocontrol agents.

Storage conditions and final considerations

However, subsequent exposure to ambient temperature often led to disease resurgence, indicating that pathogens can prevail when conditions become favorable again. Consequently, the sole application of biopesticides cannot fully replace eBective cold chain management.

In conclusion, the study suggests that biopesticides, particularly Serenade, B91, and Y126, can be valuable tools in the pre-harvest phase to reduce latent infections by Monilinia laxa, especially when applied shortly before ripening, when fruits are most susceptible.

However, their use post-harvest is insuBicient to eBectively control the disease, and must be integrated with sound storage management (and, where permitted, with selective fungicides). Moreover, selecting locally adapted microbial strains appears to be a promising strategy to enhance the eBectiveness of biocontrol approaches.

Source: Rungjindamai, N., JeBries, P., & Xu, X. (2025). EBicacy of biopesticides and fungicides against brown rot on cherry (Prunus avium) and plum (Prunus domestica). Biocontrol Science and Technology, 35(5), 479-499. https://doi.org/10.1080/09583157.2025.2473729 

Image source: Netreefruit

Andrea Giovannini
University of Bologna (ITA)


Cherry Times - All rights reserved

What to read next

Pollinators in Belgian cherry orchards: pan-traps vs netting methods

Tech management

18 Jul 2025

A study in Belgium’s cherry orchards assessed wild pollinator diversity using pan-traps and netting methods. Each technique captured different insect groups, showing that combining both provides complete data for monitoring biodiversity and planning effective conservation actions

Global cherry trade keeps expanding reaching 750,000 tons in 2023

Markets

19 Dec 2023

Chile is by far the largest cherry exporter globally, exporting 414,000 tonnes of cherries from November 2022 to February 2023. By region, Europe is the largest producer of cherries and accounts for 32% of global production.

In evidenza

Pruning cuts and bacterial canker: strategies to protect sweet cherry trees

Crop protection

18 Nov 2026

A Washington State University study of sweet cherry bacterial canker examines weather during pruning, sanitation-cut distances, and trials with lime sulfur and clove essential oil, offering clear guidance to limit infection and support an integrated prevention strategy.

ENEA identifies cherry varieties that are more resistant to insect pests

Crop protection

18 Nov 2026

ENEA research in Lazio shows that dry conditions can produce firmer cherries that are less vulnerable to Drosophila suzukii. Comparing the 2024 and 2025 seasons highlights how climate, sugar content and flesh firmness affect variety resistance and orchard management.

Tag Popolari